Brand-new or tried and true?

First published in Stuff.co.nz

When exploring retirement village options, retirees and families often face the choice between a newly developed, modern village and a well-established, older one.

Each option brings unique benefits, so understanding their differences and considering both practical needs and lifestyle preferences are key to making the right decision.

The allure of a brand-new retirement village often lies in its modern amenities, contemporary design, and the fresh opportunity to help shape the community. By contrast, established villages offer a distinctive charm, with mature landscaping, a strong sense of community, and a comforting, homelike atmosphere.

The appeal of new retirement villages

Margaret Nicholls, a resident of Metlifecare’s recently developed Pōhutukawa Landing in Beachlands, moved in 2023 after keeping her name on the waiting list for five years.

“I loved it from the day I arrived,” she shares. “I live in an apartment block, and I can see the sea. It’s warm, light, and everything works. It’s also so easy to maintain - it only takes me seven minutes to vacuum the whole apartment!”

One of the biggest draws of a new village is the modern, contemporary design. Stylish exteriors and clean, open interiors make these homes both attractive and highly functional, often requiring minimal upkeep. For Margaret, the ease of maintenance is a huge benefit.

“When I moved here, I had to give up my garden, but the landscaped grounds are brilliant” she says. “I even got to bring my potted orchids, and they’re thriving out on my deck.”

New villages also offer state-of-the-art amenities built with today’s retirees in mind. Purpose-built fitness centres, social lounges, and wellness facilities create an environment that’s active, convenient, and suited to modern lifestyles. In addition, many newer villages integrate sustainable building materials and energy-efficient technologies, which help reduce environmental impact and cut utility costs. Homes are often equipped with smart technology, allowing easy control of climate, security, and other essential features.

Another appealing aspect of a new development is the opportunity to establish strong social connections with fellow pioneers of the village. Moving in as one of the first residents provides a chance to form close friendships and shape the village’s community culture from the ground up.

For retirees who have long dreamed of a fresh, modern space with a sense of new beginnings, a brand-new village offers an ideal setting to live comfortably and purposefully.

The charm of established retirement villages

On the other hand, established villages bring their own unique advantages, and one of the most compelling reasons to consider an older village is its strong sense of community.

With well-established networks of residents and staff, these villages offer a welcoming environment that foster genuine connections. Social activities, organised events, and friendships that have developed over time create a supportive and secure atmosphere, making it easy to feel at home.

Jan Coates and her husband, Tony Dunn, who recently moved to Metlifecare’s well-established Powley Village in West Auckland, found this sense of community immediately appealing. “It’s a small village, so you don’t feel overwhelmed with people,” Jan explains. “The village itself is very friendly.”

Another standout feature of older villages is their mature landscaping. Expansive gardens, towering trees, and thoughtfully maintained grounds contribute to a serene, picturesque environment. Some villages even include walking tracks and bushwalks, making it easy for residents to enjoy the outdoors and connect with nature.

“We love the mature gardens and all the trees,” Jan adds. “We open the door and step outside into nature. It feels more like a home than anywhere else we’ve lived.”

Accommodation in established villages is often low-rise, featuring villas or units that blend seamlessly into the natural surroundings, often with their own lawn or garden spaces.

The character and charm of an older retirement village can make a significant difference in how “at home” one feels. Unique architectural styles, history, and landscaping that have grown over time add to the appeal, creating an environment that’s warm and inviting.

For Jan and Tony, Powley Village’s homelike atmosphere and access to green spaces have been a perfect match. “It doesn’t have high rises, so we don’t feel hemmed in.”

Choosing the right fit

Choosing the right retirement village depends on personal lifestyle needs and preferences. New villages offer modern amenities, fresh designs, and the chance to shape a new community, while older villages provide timeless charm, mature landscapes, and established communities. Ultimately, the best fit is where you truly feel at home.

To help find the right retirement village for you or your loved one, check out our free guide on how to choose the right village.